Skip to main content

Rohingya crisis: 'It's not genocide,' say Myanmar's hardline monks

Rohingya crisis: 'It's not genocide,' say Myanmar's hardline monks

Updated 0005 GMT (0805 HKT) November 26, 2017
Yangon, Myanmar (CNN)The monks, clad in vermillion robes and flip flops, line up from old to young to receive a meal in their alms bowls -- rice, vegetables, cookies -- all donated by local villagers.
It's a potent act of religious devotion that takes place every day across countless communities in Myanmar, an overwhelmingly Buddhist country.
But powerful clerical voices here believe their faith -- and by extension, these traditions -- is in danger.
The main threat? Islam, says Thaw Parka, a monk who speaks for a hardline, monk-led Buddhist nationalist group known as Ma Ba Tha -- the Association for the Protection of Race and Religion.
Its role in sowing anti-Muslim sentiment is coming under scrutiny as a brutal crackdown unfolds in Rahkine State in western Myanmar, sending more than 600,000 Rohingya Muslims fleeing to Bangladesh.
"It is not like what the international community is saying. It is not genocide at all," the 46-year-old abbot told CNN in September from ZayTaWon DammarYone Monastery on the outskirts of Yangon, where he leads more than 100 monks.

'Wild accusations'

Myanmar's military also denies genocide, saying it is targeting Rohingya militants that launched deadly attacks on police posts on August 25. Rohingya refugees speak of indiscriminate killings, rape and torched villages -- charges the military also reject. The UN has described it as a "textbook example of ethnic cleansing."
Thaw Parka describes these claims as "wild accusations" and believes Buddhists in the state are the main victims of the violence.
"Our ethnic people are starving. They abandoned their villages. It is impossible to make a living, (If) they remain in their village."
It's a view shared among many of the country's Buddhist majority, who have little sympathy for the Rohingya and have reacted defensively to the international outcry. Few use the term Rohingya, instead calling them "Bengali" -- a popular slur that compounds their reputation as illegal immigrants.
These attitudes confound the romantic image many in the West have of Buddhism as a tolerant faith whose adherents wouldn't hurt a fly. Monks, however, do have a long history of political activism in Asia that more recently has taken on an ultra-nationalist and extremist hue in places like Myanmar andSri Lanka.

Buddhism under siege?

It's difficult to see how Muslims, or any other religious group, could pose a threat to Myanmar's dominant religion.
Almost nine in every 10 people in this country of 51.5 million are Buddhist, compared to a Muslim population of just 1.2 million. This doesn't figure include the estimated 1.1 million Rohingya Muslims, who are stateless as Myanmar refuses to recognize them as citizens, and they are not officially included inMyanmar's 2014 census data.
Thaw Parka says that he and his group work in harmony with "educated Muslims who live among the indigenous people of Myanmar" and he only opposes Muslim extremists and terrorists that threaten Myanmar's sovereignty.
"We have many Muslims among our friends. We hang out. We work together. We do charity work together. There was no problem. But with some Muslims who are in contact with a form of extremist terrorist, it is very difficult for peaceful existence."
The monks say their fears for their faith are also fed by wider concerns about a resurgent radical Islam and the belief that Buddhism is under siege.
One English-language pamphlet produced in 2015 by the group as a "must-know, must-read, must-keep booklet for every Myanmar citizen," says different religions are "devouring" the faith of Myanmar. It warns that if Buddhist leaders don't take care "Buddha's teaching will soon disappear" -- something the booklet says already happened centuries ago in nearby Mulism-majority Malaysia and Indonesia.
Richard Horsey, a political analyst and one of the authors of a new report on Buddhist Nationalism by the International Crisis Group, says these fears are also a reflection of what modernity could mean for the monkhood as Myanmar opens up to the world under the new government of State Counsellor Aung San Suu Kyi.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

State Dept. warned White House about possible increased threats after anti-Muslim tweets

State Dept. warned White House about possible increased threats after anti-Muslim tweets STORY HIGHLIGHTS The tweets appeared to depict Muslims engaged in different acts of violence "It didn't manifest in anything actionable, but it was a big concern," one State Department official said Washington (CNN) After President  Donald Trump retweeted anti-Muslims videos on Wednesday , multiple State Department officials said the department communicated to the White House that there was concern that protests could happen at US embassies. Officials feared that the tweets, which appeared to depict Muslims engaged in different acts of violence, would spark a reprise of the violent protests at US embassies in the Middle East which are already on high security alert. Protests erupted in September 2012 following the publication of an anti-Muslim video on the internet. Embassies were on alert throughout the day, although no incidents have been reported thus far...

Beijing forces migrant workers from their homes in 'savage' demolitions

Beijing forces migrant workers from their homes in 'savage' demolitions By  Matt Rivers  and  Serenitie Wang , CNN Updated 0825 GMT (1625 HKT) December 9, 2017 Beijing (CNN) Modern Beijing was built on the backs of low-paid migrants like Zhao Guihua. The 50-something cook and cleaner is one of thousands of people critics say have been forced from their homes in the past two weeks   as part of a drive by the municipal government to shut down what it claims is unsafe and overcrowded housing. Now homeless, she's selling all her possessions and preparing to return to her village -- hundreds of miles away in Henan province in central China. "Our apartment was demolished and new housing is too expensive to afford. We're not making enough money," she says, with her shoes, cups, pans, pots, a space heater and tools spread out in front of her on a cloth on the street. "I have no choice but to go home. I...

Fact-check: Trump claims the Republican tax plan will 'cost me a fortune'

Fact-check: Trump claims the Republican tax plan will 'cost me a fortune' STORY HIGHLIGHTS "It is going to cost me a fortune, this thing," Trump said He gave a speech in St. Charles, Missouri, on Wednesday Washington (CNN) President Donald Trump  claimed on Wednesday that the Senate Republican tax plan will cost him and his family "a fortune." Trump turned to his oft-used "believe me" line during a speech in St. Charles, Missouri, telling the friendly audience that the tax plan will cost him. "America's tax code is a total dysfunctional mess. ... It is riddled with loopholes that let some special interests, including myself, in all fairness -- it is going to cost me a fortune, this thing," Trump said. "Believe me, believe me, this is not good for me." On Thursday, White House press secretary Sarah Sanders said the President was referring to "deductions that may no longer exist" that he...