Skip to main content

The world looks to America to defend press freedom


The world looks to America to defend press freedom


The world looks to America to defend press freedom

Joel Simon is executive director of the Committee to Protect Journalists. The views expressed in this commentary are his own. This is the next installment in the CNN Opinion series on the challenges facing the media, which is under attack from critics, governments and changing technology.
(CNN)For a brief period, following more than four decades of military repression, Myanmar saw an explosion of independent media. Beginning in 2011, exiled journalists flooded back into the country and started new publications. They covered the news, criticized the government and contributed to a national debate.
But when I visited the country in June as part of a delegation from the Committee to Protect Journalists, I observed serious backsliding. We met with the widow of a murdered journalist. We spoke with editors who told us they worried about going to jail. When we asked the government to amend a repressive law that makes it illegal to criticize people online, they promised to do so. But their proposed reforms were modest, leaving in place a three-year sentence for those convicted of defamation. The government was also unmoved by our appeals to allow journalists better access to Rakhine state, where government forces are engaged in a brutal campaign against the Rohingya minority.

A month later, I was in Ukraine, also on a CPJ mission. Ukraine saw a dramatic media opening following the 2014 Maidan revolution, which brought down the country's corrupt leader, Viktor Yanukovych. But those moments of euphoria are today a distant memory. We were there to push the government to investigate the murder of one of Ukraine's leading reporters, Pavel Sheremet, blown up in a car bomb a year ago. But the country -- and the media -- are deeply divided. The current president, Petro Poroshenko, draws an alarming distinction between "patriotic" and "unpatriotic" media. And fewer and fewer people believe in facts.Myanmar and Ukraine are just two countries, but they are part of a global trend. Around the world, press freedom is in steady decline, according to all of thelatest surveys. Press freedom can vanish in an instant -- as has happened inVenezuela and Egypt. Or it can slowly erode, as has occurred in Kenya, Japanand Hungary.
What do you need to lose a free press? In my view, there are two facilitating factors: declining public confidence in the media and a polarizing political environment in which most don't know what's true and those who do know don't care.

While we are a long way from such a state in the US, this is no time for complacency. The First Amendment is unique in all the world in providing legal protection for the broadest range of speech.
But press freedom as experienced today in the United States is a relatively recent construct. Just ask journalists who covered the Civil Rights movement in the South. Civil rights reporter Bill Minor, who died in March, recalled a time not that long ago when journalists faced violence, harassment and legal assault -- and the "First Amendment didn't matter." He noted one paper in Mississippi, The Lexington, which was bombed in reprisal for its reporting on police brutality of black residents. Rather than investigating the crime, the local sheriff sued for libel.
Turkey accuses journalists of terror plot 03:16
In fact, when it comes to press freedom, norms are just as important as laws. There is no law requiring that political leaders hold press conferences. It is not illegal to refuse to take questions from a tough reporter. It's not a crime to insult journalists with whom you disagree.
Laws have not changed in decades in the United States, and the Supreme Court continues to take a broad view of the First Amendment. But our norms are breaking down. We have a president who refers to journalists as enemies of the people and characterizes stories he doesn't like as fake news. So far President Donald Trump and those who echo his views are not seeking to change the laws. They are seeking to change the culture.
    The US tradition of respect for press freedom matters to people in the United States, but it also matters to all those around the world who stand up to defend these rights, people in places where they are under threat.
    At a July photo op on the sidelines of the G-20 meeting in Germany, Russian President Vladimir Putin reportedly pointed to the assembled journalists and whispered to Trump, "Are these the ones who are insulting you?"
    "Those are the ones," Trump replied. They had a good laugh. But Russia is a place where dozens of journalists have been murdered. There's nothing funny about that.
    Watch journalist violently arrested while covering GOP nominee 02:21
    We need an American president who defends press freedom rather than mocks it. Around the world, journalists in places like Myanmar and Ukraine risk their lives to report the news. Do we as Americans value and respect their sacrifice? Or do we laugh in amusement as press freedom is rolled back, and journalists confront violence and repression?

    Comments

    Popular posts from this blog

    State Dept. warned White House about possible increased threats after anti-Muslim tweets

    State Dept. warned White House about possible increased threats after anti-Muslim tweets STORY HIGHLIGHTS The tweets appeared to depict Muslims engaged in different acts of violence "It didn't manifest in anything actionable, but it was a big concern," one State Department official said Washington (CNN) After President  Donald Trump retweeted anti-Muslims videos on Wednesday , multiple State Department officials said the department communicated to the White House that there was concern that protests could happen at US embassies. Officials feared that the tweets, which appeared to depict Muslims engaged in different acts of violence, would spark a reprise of the violent protests at US embassies in the Middle East which are already on high security alert. Protests erupted in September 2012 following the publication of an anti-Muslim video on the internet. Embassies were on alert throughout the day, although no incidents have been reported thus far...
    Powerful Iran-Iraq earthquake is deadliest of 2017 IRNA has published more photos showing the destruction the earthquake wrought on Sarpol-e Zahab, Iran. The moment the Iran-Iraq earthquake struck   01:08 If you are in a safe place and have video from the earthquake, you can share it with CNN via WhatsApp at +1 347 322 0415. Please do not put yourself in danger. Tehran, Iran (CNN) At least 452 people were killed and thousands injured after a powerful earthquake struck near the border of Iran and Iraq late Sunday. The earthquake is the deadliest of the year, eclipsing the one that  hit Mexico City in September , and was felt as far away as Turkey and Pakistan. Around 100 of the dead are believed to be from one town in Iran's Kermanshah province, the country's semi-official Mehr news agency reported. In response to an outpouring of sympathy and offers to help, Iranian Foreign Minister Javad Zarif issued the following statement on Monday: "Heart...

    Russia investigation zeroes in on Trump inner circle

    Russia investigation zeroes in on Trump inner circle STORY HIGHLIGHTS Mueller charged Flynn with one count of lying to the FBI It raises questions about how high up Mueller's investigation will reach Washington (CNN) Michael Flynn's downfall  Friday exacerbated grave legal and political risks that represent the most serious threat to any administration for at least 40 years, and could eventually imperil the Trump presidency itself. The plea deal cut by the fired national security adviser with Special Counsel Robert Mueller undermines much of what the White House has said about the Russia controversy engulfing the presidency. It means there is now no credible way for  President Donald Trump  to claim the Russia investigation is a hoax, made up, fake news or a witch hunt. It raises questions about who higher up the chain of command in Trump's orbit -- possibly even including the President himself -- is in Mueller's sights after he agreed to...